At Vanscoy, Maurer and Bash Diamond Jewelers in Lancaster, PA, we see engagement rings as more than just beautiful pieces of jewelry. They are personal statements, sparkling symbols of your love story, and let’s be honest, they are also style icons in their own right. If you have ever looked at a celebrity’s engagement ring and thought, “Wow, that’s exactly my vibe,” you are not alone. The trendsetters, red carpet favorites, and modern muses give us endless inspiration. Today we are rounding up “It Girl” engagement ring styles that will make your heart skip a beat and have everyone asking, “Where did you get that ring?”
1. The Timeless Solitaire
Hailee Steinfeld's engagement ring from Josh Allen embodies timeless elegance in its pure, classic design. A solitaire diamond engagement ring is the definition of effortless chic. It is sleek, simple, and lets the diamond take center stage. This style is perfect if you love a ring that looks just as beautiful with jeans and a tee as it does with a little black dress. Solitaires have an understated confidence, and that is exactly what makes them “It Girl” worthy.
2. The Oval Obsession
Hailey Bieber’s oval-cut engagement ring created a wave of oval fever across the jewelry world. Ovals are elongating, feminine, and feel fresh without being too trendy. They sparkle in every setting, from solitaire to halo, and give your ring that effortlessly glam aesthetic. If you want your ring to photograph beautifully at every angle, an oval cut is a fantastic choice.

3. The Glamorous Halo
Beyoncé’s radiant cut diamond with a halo is proof that halos will always have superstar appeal. This style encircles your center diamond with a glittering frame of smaller stones, amplifying the sparkle and giving your ring a dramatic effect. Halos are perfect for anyone who loves a touch of extra glamour and wants their engagement ring to shine from across the room.
4. The Vintage Revival
Lily Collins’ rose-cut diamond with a halo of smaller diamonds is a dreamy nod to vintage design. Vintage-inspired rings are perfect for brides who love romance, artistry, and a sense of timelessness. Intricate detailing like milgrain edges, filigree, and unique diamond cuts make vintage rings look like heirlooms passed down through generations. Choosing a vintage-inspired ring shows you have an eye for style that goes beyond the trends.

5. The Emerald-Cut Icon
Jennifer Lopez has been spotted with more than one emerald-cut engagement ring, and each time it makes headlines. This cut is all about sophistication and confidence. With its step-cut facets and rectangular shape, the emerald cut has a mirror-like effect that feels bold yet elegant. It is the perfect choice if you love clean lines, modern glamour, and a bit of old Hollywood charm.
6. The Colored Gemstone Twist
Not every “It Girl” says yes to a diamond. Kate Middleton’s royal sapphire is one of the most famous engagement rings in the world. Choosing a colored gemstone, whether it is a sapphire, emerald, ruby, or even a pastel morganite, is a bold way to show off your individuality. Colored gemstones make a ring stand out in a sea of traditional styles, and they give a unique pop of personality to your look.

7. The Three-Stone Symbol
Meghan Markle again set the stage with her stunning three-stone diamond ring, symbolizing the past, present, and future of a relationship. A three-stone ring is deeply meaningful while still being strikingly stylish. The side stones can be diamonds or gemstones, adding color and character to the design. This style is perfect for someone who loves symbolism as much as sparkle.
8. The Pear-Shaped Stunner
Ariana Grande’s pear-shaped engagement ring with an offset design turned heads for its playful and modern take on a classic cut. Pear-shaped diamonds combine the brilliance of a round cut with the uniqueness of a marquise, giving your ring a fresh and unexpected flair. Whether you wear the point up or down, this style has a distinctive personality that says you are not afraid to stand out.
9. The Modern Minimalist
For the “It Girl” who loves sleek lines and chic design, minimalist engagement rings are the way to go. Think thin gold bands, bezel settings, or asymmetrical styles. Zoë Kravitz’s delicate, understated ring shows that less really can be more. Minimalist rings are versatile, elegant, and let your personal style shine through every day.
10. The Custom Creation
The ultimate “It Girl” move is designing your very own ring. Celebrities from Blake Lively to Kourtney Kardashian have shown off custom creations that are completely unique to them. When you create a custom engagement ring at Vanscoy, Maurer and Bash, you get to bring your vision to life, whether it is mixing diamond cuts, adding hidden details, or designing something entirely one of a kind.

Finding Your “It Girl” Ring in Lancaster
At Vanscoy, Maurer and Bash Diamond Jewelers, we love helping you find (or create) a ring that makes you feel like the main character of your own story. Whether you are inspired by Hollywood icons or simply want something that reflects your unique style, we have the expertise and passion to guide you. Stop by our Lancaster showroom and let us help you design the ring that will make you sparkle like the “It Girl” you already are.