At Vanscoy, Maurer & Bash Diamond Jewelers in Lancaster, Pennsylvania we believe that anniversaries are milestones begging to be celebrated in sparkle and style. An anniversary band is much more than jewelry. It's a symbol of shared memories and future promises. If you're considering gifting or choosing an anniversary band, we’ve rounded up things to know, plus ideas inspired by pieces from our shop and comparable styles. Use this guide to pick something that shines as bright as your love!

engaged couple kissing

What to Know Before You Choose an Anniversary Band

  1. Metal Matters
    Precious metals like yellow gold, white gold, rose gold, and platinum each have personality. Platinum is durable and bright white. Yellow gold has warmth. Rose gold has romantic rosy tones. If your partner already wears jewelry in one metal more than others, there’s your hint on which to choose!

  2. Diamond Styles & Settings
    Diamonds can be set in many ways: pavé, shared prong, channel, bezel, etc. Each setting influences how much sparkle shows and how the band holds up with wear. For example, shared prong settings let more light hit the stones from sides which boosts sparkle but may need occasional inspection. Pavé gives a continuous shimmer across many small diamonds.

  3. Eternity vs Partial vs Stackable Bands
    Eternity bands circle the entire finger with diamonds. Partial bands (half-eternity or three-stone or other styles) have diamonds on part of the band leaving some metal exposed. Stackable bands are thinner bands designed to wear alongside another ring, often mixing metals or styles.

  4. Comfort & Fit
    Think about everyday wear. Comfort fit bands are rounded inside. Wider bands may feel more substantial but can also be less comfortable if you’re not used to them. Also: how the anniversary band will pair with an engagement or wedding band matters. You want them to complement each other in profile and style.

  5. Budget & Value
    Decide on a budget that makes sense first. The carat weight, quality of diamonds, metal type all affect cost. Sometimes investing a bit more in craftsmanship yields something that lasts longer and is more meaningful.

Anniversary Band Ideas From VMB


diamond engagement ring and diamond eternity band

What to Choose Based on Anniversary Years or Preference

Here are some casual guidelines:

  • For early anniversaries (1-5 years) something elegant and sentimental like a partial band or small pavé may feel fitting.

  • As you approach bigger milestones (10 years, 25 years) an eternity band or a full-carat diamond option often matches the gravity of the moment.

  • If your partner is very active with hands or jobs involving a lot of work wearing rings, keep durability and setting security top of mind.

engaged couple smiling arm in arm

At Vanscoy, Maurer & Bash Diamond Jewelers, we feel honored to help couples celebrate life’s biggest moments. Whether you want something subtle, bold, traditional, or one-of-a-kind, we’ll help you find the perfect ring to say, “I’d choose you all over again.”

×